A Tangent and a Secant
From point \(P\), a tangent \(PT\) and a secant \(PAB\) are drawn to a circle. Given \(PA=5\), \(PT=10\), find \(PB\).
Use \(PT^2=PA\cdot PB\).
By power of a point, \(PT^2=PA\cdot PB\). Hence \(100=5\cdot PB\), so \(PB=20\).
Chapter
Theory
In a mixed problem, the method is not announced in advance. First one has to see the structure: circles, tangents, ratios, midpoints, parallel lines, and intersections of lines. A good solution begins not with computation, but with choosing the tool.
The same fact can often be proved in several ways. For example, concyclicity may follow from angles, power of a point, a circle equation, or a Miquel point. The goal of this module is to learn how to choose the shortest route.
For circles, use inscribed angles, the tangent-chord theorem, power of a point \(PA\cdot PB=PC\cdot PD\), and equality of powers on the radical axis.
For ratios on sides, use Ceva and Menelaus, areas with a common height, similarity, and homothety. For configurations of four lines, a Miquel point often appears.
If the configuration contains right angles, midpoints, a circle equation, or too many lengths, coordinates and vectors can replace a long synthetic solution.
Try power of a point when two secants, or a tangent and a secant, come from one point. The radical axis is useful when one needs to prove collinearity of points related to several circles.
Ceva points to concurrence, Menelaus to collinearity. Areas help when there is a common height or a ratio on a side. The Miquel point appears in configurations of four lines and three or four circles.
Ask: what must be proved? Concyclicity usually calls for angles or power of a point. Collinearity involving circles often calls for the radical axis. Concurrence of cevians calls for Ceva or areas.
If the problem contains an “intersection of tangents”, look for power of a point or homothety. If there are “four lines”, check for a complete quadrilateral and a Miquel point. If the synthetic picture is overloaded, choose coordinates.
The first mistake is starting with a favourite method instead of the clues in the problem. The second is applying Ceva when the goal is collinearity, or Menelaus when the goal is concurrence.
The third mistake is forgetting directed lengths in problems with exterior points. The fourth is proving concyclicity by angles when a one-line power-of-a-point argument already solves the problem.
Before solving, mark the goal: concyclicity, collinearity, concurrence, a ratio, or a length. Then find the main object: a circle, a point, a line, a ratio, a tangent, or a complete quadrilateral. After that, choose the tool and only then begin computations or angle chasing.
Examples
If a tangent and a secant come from one point, angle chasing is usually unnecessary.
Problem. From point \(P\), a tangent \(PT\) and a secant \(PAB\) are drawn to a circle. Given \(PA=4\), \(PT=6\), find \(PB\).
By power of a point, \(PT^2=PA\cdot PB\). Hence \(36=4\cdot PB\), so \(PB=9\).
Comment. The main clue is a tangent and a secant from the same point.
Sometimes the circle should be seen as a circle with a diameter.
Problem. In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\) and \(E\) are the feet of the altitudes from \(B\) and \(C\). Prove that \(B,C,D,E\) lie on one circle.
We have \(\angle BDC=90^\circ\) and \(\angle BEC=90^\circ\). Thus points \(D\) and \(E\) lie on the circle with diameter \(BC\). Therefore \(B,C,D,E\) are concyclic.
Collinearity in a problem with several circles often points to radical axes.
Problem. Circles \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\) meet at \(A,B\). Point \(P\) lies on line \(AB\). A line through \(P\) meets \(\omega_1\) at \(X,Y\), and another line through \(P\) meets \(\omega_2\) at \(U,V\). Prove that \(PX\cdot PY=PU\cdot PV\).
Line \(AB\) is the radical axis of circles \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\). Hence the powers of point \(P\) with respect to the two circles are equal. Therefore \(PX\cdot PY=PU\cdot PV\).
If one needs to prove that three lines meet, first check Ceva.
Problem. In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D,E,F\) lie on \(BC,CA,AB\), respectively. Suppose \(BD:DC=2:3\), \(CE:EA=3:4\), \(AF:FB=2:1\). Prove that \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent.
By Ceva's theorem it is enough to check the product: \(\frac{BD}{DC}\cdot\frac{CE}{EA}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}=\frac{2}{3}\cdot\frac{3}{4}\cdot 2=1\). Hence the lines are concurrent.
A ratio on a side is often equal to a ratio of areas with a common height.
Problem. In triangle \(ABC\), point \(D\) lies on \(BC\), and \(BD:DC=3:5\). Prove that \([ABD]:[ACD]=3:5\).
Triangles \(ABD\) and \(ACD\) have the same altitude from \(A\) to line \(BC\). Therefore their areas are proportional to their bases: \([ABD]:[ACD]=BD:DC=3:5\).
Four lines and four circles are almost always a signal for a Miquel point.
Problem. In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\in AB\), \(E\in AC\), and lines \(BE\) and \(CD\) meet at \(P\). Prove that circles \((ABE)\), \((ACD)\), \((BDP)\), \((CEP)\) have one common point.
Consider the four lines \(AB,AC,BE,CD\). Their triples form the circles \((ABE)\), \((ACD)\), \((BDP)\), \((CEP)\). By Miquel's theorem for a complete quadrilateral, these circles pass through one point.
If a ratio comes from a projection, coordinates give a short solution.
Problem. In triangle \(A(0,0)\), \(B(6,0)\), \(C(0,8)\), point \(P\) is the foot of the perpendicular from \(A\) to \(BC\). Find \(BP:PC\).
Write \(P=B+t(C-B)=(6-6t,8t)\). The vector \(BC=(-6,8)\), and the condition \(AP\perp BC\) gives \((6-6t,8t)\cdot(-6,8)=0\). Thus \(-36+100t=0\), so \(t=\frac{9}{25}\). Therefore \(BP:PC=t:(1-t)=9:16\).
A strong problem is often solved by mixing tangents, angles, and the sine rule.
Problem. In triangle \(ABC\), the tangent to the circumcircle at \(A\) meets line \(BC\) at \(T\). Prove that \(TB:TC=AB^2:AC^2\).
By the tangent-chord theorem, \(\angle TAB=\angle ACB\), and \(\angle TAC=\angle ABC\). Applying the sine rule in triangles \(TAB\) and \(TAC\), we get \(\frac{TB}{TC}=\frac{\sin^2\angle ACB}{\sin^2\angle ABC}\). By the sine rule in \(ABC\), this equals \(\frac{AB^2}{AC^2}\).
Problems
From point \(P\), a tangent \(PT\) and a secant \(PAB\) are drawn to a circle. Given \(PA=5\), \(PT=10\), find \(PB\).
Use \(PT^2=PA\cdot PB\).
By power of a point, \(PT^2=PA\cdot PB\). Hence \(100=5\cdot PB\), so \(PB=20\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\) and \(E\) are the feet of the altitudes from \(B\) and \(C\). Prove that \(B,C,D,E\) lie on one circle.
Find two right angles subtending the same segment.
Since \(BD\perp CD\), \(\angle BDC=90^\circ\). Since \(BE\perp CE\), \(\angle BEC=90^\circ\). Thus \(D\) and \(E\) lie on the circle with diameter \(BC\), so \(B,C,D,E\) are concyclic.
Circles \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\) meet at \(A,B\). Point \(P\) lies on line \(AB\). A line through \(P\) meets \(\omega_1\) at \(X,Y\), and another line through \(P\) meets \(\omega_2\) at \(U,V\). Prove that \(PX\cdot PY=PU\cdot PV\).
Line \(AB\) is the radical axis of the two circles.
Point \(P\) lies on the radical axis, so its powers with respect to \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\) are equal. By the definition of power, \(PX\cdot PY=PU\cdot PV\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D,E,F\) lie on \(BC,CA,AB\). Given \(BD:DC=2:3\), \(CE:EA=3:4\), \(AF:FB=2:1\). Prove that \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent.
For concurrence of three cevians, check Ceva's product.
\(\frac{BD}{DC}\cdot\frac{CE}{EA}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}=\frac{2}{3}\cdot\frac{3}{4}\cdot 2=1\). By Ceva's theorem, lines \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent.
Point \(P\) lies inside triangle \(ABC\). Line \(AP\) meets \(BC\) at \(D\). Given \([PAB]:[PBC]:[PCA]=2:3:4\), find \(BD:DC\).
Compare areas \([PAB]\) and \([PCA]\); they give the ratio \(BD:DC\).
Triangles \(PAB\) and \(PCA\) are conveniently compared using the common base \(AP\). Their altitudes to line \(AP\), drawn from \(B\) and \(C\), are in the ratio \(BD:DC\), because \(B,D,C\) are collinear. Hence \(BD:DC=[PAB]:[PCA]=2:4=1:2\).
In triangle \(ABC\), the tangent to the circumcircle at \(A\) meets line \(BC\) at \(T\). Prove in directed lengths that \(TA^2=TB\cdot TC\).
Consider the power of point \(T\) with respect to the circumcircle.
From point \(T\), tangent \(TA\) and secant \(TBC\) are drawn to the circle. Hence by power of a point, \(TA^2=TB\cdot TC\) in directed lengths.
In a convex cyclic quadrilateral \(ABCD\), diagonals \(AC\) and \(BD\) meet at \(P\). Prove that \(PA\cdot PC=PB\cdot PD\).
Point \(P\) has the same power with respect to the circle along two secants.
Lines \(PAC\) and \(PBD\) are two secants of the same circle. By power of a point, \(PA\cdot PC=PB\cdot PD\).
Circles \(\omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3\) meet pairwise: \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\) at \(A,B\), \(\omega_2\) and \(\omega_3\) at \(C,D\), and \(\omega_3\) and \(\omega_1\) at \(E,F\). Suppose lines \(AB\) and \(CD\) meet at \(X\). Prove that \(X\) lies on line \(EF\).
Point \(X\) has equal powers with respect to the first two circles and also the second and third.
Since \(X\in AB\), it lies on the radical axis of \(\omega_1,\omega_2\), so \(\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_1}(X)=\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_2}(X)\). Since \(X\in CD\), we get \(\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_2}(X)=\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_3}(X)\). Therefore \(\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_1}(X)=\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_3}(X)\), so \(X\) lies on the radical axis of \(\omega_1,\omega_3\), which is line \(EF\).
In triangle \(ABC\), point \(D\) lies on \(AB\), point \(E\) lies on \(BC\), and point \(F\) lies on the extension of \(CA\) beyond \(A\). Suppose \(AD:DB=1:2\), \(BE:EC=2:3\), \(AF:FC=1:3\). Prove that \(D,E,F\) are collinear.
For collinearity of points on sides and one extension, apply Menelaus.
Since \(F\) lies on the extension beyond \(A\), \(CF:FA=3:1\). Check Menelaus' product: \(\frac{AD}{DB}\cdot\frac{BE}{EC}\cdot\frac{CF}{FA}=\frac{1}{2}\cdot\frac{2}{3}\cdot 3=1\). Hence \(D,E,F\) are collinear.
In triangle \(A(0,0)\), \(B(6,0)\), \(C(0,8)\), point \(P\) is the foot of the perpendicular from \(A\) to \(BC\). Find \(BP:PC\).
Write \(P=B+t(C-B)\) and use \(\overrightarrow{AP}\cdot\overrightarrow{BC}=0\).
We have \(P=(6,0)+t(-6,8)=(6-6t,8t)\). The perpendicularity condition is \((6-6t,8t)\cdot(-6,8)=0\). Thus \(-36+36t+64t=0\), so \(t=\frac{9}{25}\). Hence \(BP:PC=t:(1-t)=9:16\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\in AB\), \(E\in AC\), with \(DE\parallel BC\) and \(AD:DB=2:3\). Find \([ADE]:[ABC]\).
Triangles \(ADE\) and \(ABC\) are similar with homothety centre \(A\).
Since \(AD:DB=2:3\), we have \(AD:AB=2:5\). From \(DE\parallel BC\), \(\triangle ADE\sim\triangle ABC\) with scale factor \(\frac{2}{5}\). Areas of similar triangles are in the square of the scale factor, so \([ADE]:[ABC]=4:25\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\in AB\), \(E\in AC\), and lines \(BE\) and \(CD\) meet at \(P\). Prove that circles \((ABE)\), \((ACD)\), \((BDP)\), \((CEP)\) have one common point.
Consider the complete quadrilateral formed by lines \(AB,AC,BE,CD\).
The four lines \(AB,AC,BE,CD\) form a complete quadrilateral. Its four circles are exactly \((ABE)\), \((ACD)\), \((BDP)\), \((CEP)\). By Miquel's theorem, they pass through one point.
Two circles touch externally at \(T\). Their common external tangent touches the circles at \(A\) and \(B\). Prove that \(\angle ATB=90^\circ\).
Choose the common tangent as the \(Ox\)-axis and put the centres at \((0,r)\) and \((d,s)\).
Let \(A=(0,0)\), \(B=(d,0)\), and let the circle centres be \(O_1=(0,r)\), \(O_2=(d,s)\). Since the circles touch externally, \(O_1O_2=r+s\), so \(d^2+(s-r)^2=(r+s)^2\), hence \(d^2=4rs\). The tangency point \(T\) divides \(O_1O_2\) in the ratio \(r:s\), so \(T=\left(\frac{rd}{r+s},\frac{2rs}{r+s}\right)\). Then \(\overrightarrow{TA}\cdot\overrightarrow{TB}=\frac{rs(4rs-d^2)}{(r+s)^2}=0\). Therefore \(TA\perp TB\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\in BC\), \(E\in CA\). Lines \(AD\) and \(BE\) meet at \(P\), and line \(CP\) meets \(AB\) at \(F\). If \(BD:DC=2:1\), \(CE:EA=3:2\), find \(AF:FB\).
Since \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent, apply Ceva.
By Ceva's theorem, \(\frac{BD}{DC}\cdot\frac{CE}{EA}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}=1\). Hence \(2\cdot\frac{3}{2}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}=1\), so \(\frac{AF}{FB}=\frac{1}{3}\). Therefore \(AF:FB=1:3\).
Two lines meet at \(P\). Points \(A,B\) lie on one ray from \(P\), and points \(C,D\) lie on another ray, with \(PA
Draw the circle through \(A,C,D\) and look where it meets ray \(PB\) for the second time.
Let the circle through \(A,C,D\) meet ray \(PB\) for the second time at \(X\). By power of point \(P\), \(PA\cdot PX=PC\cdot PD\). By the condition, \(PC\cdot PD=PA\cdot PB\). Since \(PA\ne 0\), \(PX=PB\). On one ray such a point is unique, so \(X=B\). Hence \(A,C,B,D\) are concyclic.
Circles \(\omega_1\) and \(\omega_2\) meet at \(A,B\). Point \(P\) lies on line \(AB\). From \(P\), tangents \(PX\) to \(\omega_1\) and \(PY\) to \(\omega_2\) are drawn. Prove that \(PX=PY\).
Point \(P\) lies on the radical axis, so its powers with respect to the circles are equal.
Line \(AB\) is the radical axis, so \(\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_1}(P)=\operatorname{Pow}_{\omega_2}(P)\). These powers are \(PX^2\) and \(PY^2\), because \(PX\) and \(PY\) are tangents. Therefore \(PX^2=PY^2\), hence \(PX=PY\).
In quadrilateral \(ABCD\), lines \(AB\) and \(CD\) meet at \(E\), while \(AD\) and \(BC\) meet at \(F\). Let \(M\) be the Miquel point of the four lines \(AB,BC,CD,DA\). Prove that \(\angle AMB=\angle DFC\).
Point \(M\) lies on circle \((ABF)\).
By Miquel's theorem, \(A,B,F,M\) lie on one circle. Therefore \(\angle AMB=\angle AFB\), since these angles subtend chord \(AB\). But \(FA\) is the same line as \(FD\), and \(FB\) is the same line as \(FC\). Hence \(\angle AFB=\angle DFC\). Therefore \(\angle AMB=\angle DFC\).
The tangents to a circle at \(A\) and \(C\) meet at \(T\). A line through \(T\) meets the circle at \(B\) and \(D\). Prove that \(TA=TC\) and \(TB\cdot TD=TA^2\).
Use equality of tangents from one point and the power of point \(T\).
Tangents drawn from one point to a circle are equal, so \(TA=TC\). Also, the power of point \(T\) with respect to the circle equals both \(TA^2\) and \(TB\cdot TD\) along secant \(TBD\). Therefore \(TB\cdot TD=TA^2\).
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D,E,F\) lie on \(BC,CA,AB\). Given \([ABD]:[ACD]=2:3\), \([BCE]:[BAE]=3:4\), \([CAF]:[CBF]=2:1\). Prove that \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent.
Convert area ratios into segment ratios on the sides.
Since each corresponding pair of triangles has a common height, we get \(BD:DC=2:3\), \(CE:EA=3:4\), \(AF:FB=2:1\). Then \(\frac{BD}{DC}\cdot\frac{CE}{EA}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}=\frac{2}{3}\cdot\frac{3}{4}\cdot 2=1\). By Ceva, lines \(AD,BE,CF\) are concurrent.
Two disjoint circles of different radii are given. Their common external tangents touch the first circle at \(A,B\) and the second at \(C,D\), with \(A,C\) on one tangent and \(B,D\) on the other. Prove that lines \(AC\) and \(BD\) meet on the line of the centres of the circles.
Recall the external homothety centre of two circles.
There is an external homothety sending the first circle to the second; its centre \(X\) lies on the line of the centres. A common external tangent maps to itself, so the tangency point \(A\) maps to \(C\), and \(B\) maps to \(D\). Therefore \(A,X,C\) are collinear and \(B,X,D\) are collinear. Hence lines \(AC\) and \(BD\) meet at \(X\) on the line of the centres.
In triangle \(ABC\), points \(D\in BC\), \(E\in CA\), \(F\in AB\). Prove that circles \((AEF)\), \((BFD)\), \((CDE)\) have one common point.
Take the second intersection of circles \((AEF)\) and \((BFD)\), then prove that it lies on \((CDE)\).
Let circles \((AEF)\) and \((BFD)\) meet again at \(M\). We need to prove that \(C,D,E,M\) are cyclic. From \(M\in(BFD)\), \(\angle DMF=\angle DBF=\angle CBA\). From \(M\in(AEF)\), \(\angle FME=\angle FAE=\angle BAC\). Therefore \(\angle DME=\angle DMF+\angle FME=\angle CBA+\angle BAC=180^\circ-\angle BCA\). But \(\angle DCE=\angle BCA\). Thus \(\angle DME+\angle DCE=180^\circ\), and \(C,D,E,M\) lie on one circle.
In an acute triangle \(ABC\), circles with diameters \(AB\), \(BC\), \(CA\) are drawn. Prove that their radical centre is the orthocenter of triangle \(ABC\).
Prove that the radical axis of the circles with diameters \(AB\) and \(AC\) is the altitude from \(A\).
For a point \(X\), the power with respect to the circle with diameter \(AB\) is \(\overrightarrow{XA}\cdot\overrightarrow{XB}\), and with respect to the circle with diameter \(AC\) it is \(\overrightarrow{XA}\cdot\overrightarrow{XC}\). Equality of powers gives \(\overrightarrow{XA}\cdot(\overrightarrow{XB}-\overrightarrow{XC})=0\), that is \(XA\perp BC\). Hence the radical axis of these two circles is the altitude from \(A\). Similarly, the other two radical axes are the altitudes from \(B\) and \(C\). Their common point is the orthocenter.
In triangle \(ABC\), the median \(AM\) and cevian \(AD\) to side \(BC\) are isogonal, that is, \(\angle BAD=\angle MAC\) and \(\angle CAD=\angle MAB\). Prove that \(BD:DC=AB^2:AC^2\).
First express \(BD:DC\) through the areas of \(ABD\) and \(ACD\), then use equality of the areas of \(ABM\) and \(ACM\).
Since triangles \(ABD\) and \(ACD\) have the same altitude from \(A\), \(\frac{BD}{DC}=\frac{[ABD]}{[ACD]}\). Also, \(\frac{[ABD]}{[ACD]}=\frac{AB\cdot AD\sin\angle BAD}{AC\cdot AD\sin\angle CAD}=\frac{AB\sin\angle BAD}{AC\sin\angle CAD}\). The median \(AM\) divides the triangle into equal areas, so \(AB\sin\angle MAB=AC\sin\angle MAC\). By isogonality, \(\sin\angle BAD=\sin\angle MAC\), and \(\sin\angle CAD=\sin\angle MAB\). Therefore \(\frac{BD}{DC}=\frac{AB}{AC}\cdot\frac{\sin\angle MAC}{\sin\angle MAB}=\frac{AB}{AC}\cdot\frac{AB}{AC}=\frac{AB^2}{AC^2}\).
In a convex cyclic quadrilateral \(ABCD\), diagonals \(AC\) and \(BD\) meet at \(P\). Prove that \(\frac{PA}{PC}=\frac{AB\cdot AD}{CB\cdot CD}\).
Find two pairs of similar triangles: \(PAB\) and \(PDC\), then \(PAD\) and \(PBC\).
Since \(ABCD\) is cyclic, \(\angle PAB=\angle CAB=\angle CDB=\angle PDC\), and \(\angle PBA=\angle DBA=\angle DCA=\angle PCD\). Hence \(\triangle PAB\sim\triangle PDC\), so \(\frac{PB}{PC}=\frac{AB}{DC}\). Similarly, \(\triangle PAD\sim\triangle PBC\), hence \(\frac{PA}{PB}=\frac{AD}{BC}\). Multiplying these equalities gives \(\frac{PA}{PC}=\frac{AD}{BC}\cdot\frac{AB}{DC}=\frac{AB\cdot AD}{CB\cdot CD}\).
Ladders